Opinion & Analysis

Bits and Power: An Energy-Digital Agenda for The Netherlands and Europe

In short

  • Electrification and digitalisation are closely interconnected domains where vulnerabilities exist, but they are also areas where Europe has significant strengths.
  • The EU and the Netherlands are expanding policies and financial instruments to reduce cybersecurity risks and excessive dependency on foreign hardware and software suppliers, while also creating leverage over others.
  • Policy focus should be placed in supporting innovation at home, fostering European ecosystems in the energy-digital nexus and help promising start-ups to scale up and compete globally.

Europe’s energy and digital transitions are fundamentally intertwined. Energy systems are increasingly dependent on and optimised by Artificial Intelligence (AI)-driven applications, cloud services and semiconductors, while digital infrastructure relies upon and requires a secure supply and enormous amounts of energy. This energy-digital nexus creates new geoeconomic vulnerabilities for the European Union (EU) and the Netherlands, but it also offers significant opportunities for innovation, competitiveness and broader strategic autonomy. Electrification and digitalisation are moreover key ingredients to making Europe more strategically autonomous.

This report argues that developing stronger European levers at the energy-digital nexus first demands consolidating the current paradigm shift from economic efficiency to economic security: that is, from an efficiency-first mindset towards a resilience-first mindset. Doing so requires recognising that strengthening strategic capabilities entails short-term costs, while also acknowledging that the costs of inaction via potential coercion and disruption are potentially likely to be much higher in the long term.

The report identifies three main challenges. First, the EU remains overly heavily dependent on foreign suppliers for critical raw materials (CRMs), green lowcarbon technologies, semiconductors, cloud services and advanced AI models. Second, the digitalisation of energy systems increases the attack surface for cyber and hybrid security threats. Third, as the energy-digital nexus cuts across core national security interests, including defence, fragmentation across EU- and national-level policies and investments weakens collective responses to strategic challenges.

About the authors:

Louise van Schaik is Head of Unit EU & Global Affairs. She also coordinates Clingendael research in the field of critical resources.

Alexandre F. Gomes is a Research Fellow at Clingendael, where he is part of the EU & Global Affairs Unit and of the ‘Geopolitics of Technology and Digitalisation’ programme.

Hannah Lentschig is a Research Associate affiliated with the Critical Resources Programme at Clingendael’s EU & Global Affairs Unit.

Rick Bosman is Senior Research Fellow Climate Resilience and Energy Transition in the Critical Resources Programme of the EU & Global Affairs Unit at Clingendael.

Access the original publication here